Knocking on Heaven's Door - Lisa Randall [142]
If the Higgs boson defies expectations and is not light, but turns out to be heavier than twice the W boson mass (but less than twice the top quark mass), the Higgs search will be relatively simple. The Higgs with a big enough mass would decay to the W bosons or Z bosons practically all the time. (See Figure 52 for decay into Ws.) Experimenters know how to identify the Ws and Zs that would remain, so Higgs discovery wouldn’t be very hard.
[ FIGURE 52 ] A heavy Higgs boson can decay to W gauge bosons.
The next most likely decay mode in this relatively heavy Higgs scenario would involve a bottom quark and its antiparticle. However, the rate for the decay into a bottom quark and its antiparticles would be much smaller because the bottom quark has much smaller mass—and hence much smaller interaction with the Higgs boson—than the W gauge boson. A Higgs heavy enough to decay into Ws will turn into bottom quarks less than one percent of the time. Decays to lighter particles would happen less frequently still. So if the Higgs boson is relatively heavy—heavier than we expect—it will decay to weak gauge bosons. And those decays would be relatively easy to see.
However, as suggested earlier, theory coupled with experimental data about the Standard Model tell us the Higgs boson is likely to be so light that it won’t decay into weak gauge bosons. The most frequent decay in this case would be into a bottom quark in conjunction with its antiparticle—the bottom antiquark (see Figure 53)—and this decay is challenging to observe. One problem is that when protons collide, lots of strongly interacting quarks and gluons are produced. And these can easily be confused with the small number of bottom quarks that will emerge from a hypothetical Higgs boson decay. On top of that, so many top quarks will be produced at the LHC that their decays to bottom quarks will also mask the Higgs signal. Theorists and experimenters are hard at work trying to see if there is any way to harness the bottom-antibottom final state of Higgs decay. Even so, despite the bigger rate, this mode probably isn’t the most promising way to discover the Higgs at the LHC—though theorists and experimenters are likely to find ways to capitalize on it.
[ FIGURE 53 ] A light Higgs boson will decay primarily to bottom quarks.
So experimenters have to investigate alternative final states from Higgs decays, even though they will occur less frequently. The most promising candidates are tau-antitau or a pair of photons. Recall that taus are the heaviest of the three types of charged leptons and are the heaviest particles aside from bottom quarks that a Higgs boson can decay into. The rate to photons is much smaller—Higgs bosons decay into photons only through quantum virtual effects—but photons are relatively easy to detect. Although the mode is challenging, experiments will be able to measure photon properties so well once enough Higgs bosons decay that they will indeed be able to identify the Higgs boson that decays into them.
In fact, because of the criticality of Higgs discovery, CMS and ATLAS put elaborate and careful search strategies in place to find photons and taus, and