Lost - Michael Robotham [95]
“A girl who is supposed to be dead.”
“Someone had sent a ransom demand to Rachel Carlyle alleging that her daughter was still alive.”
“And you believed this letter?”
“I agreed to have the hair tested.”
The Rook is more insistent. “You still haven’t explained why you asked a private laboratory to conduct the test.”
“It was a favor for Mrs. Carlyle. I didn’t believe the hair would be a match for her daughter.”
“You wanted to keep it a secret?”
“No. I was concerned that any official request would be misconstrued. I didn’t want it perceived that I had doubts about the original investigation.”
“You wanted to deny Mr. Wavell his right to natural justice?”
“I wanted to be sure.”
The Rook walks back to the table and picks up a second sheet of paper, snapping it with his fingers as though calling the edges to attention.
Why doesn’t he ask me the result of the DNA test? Perhaps he doesn’t know the answer. If the hair didn’t match Mickey’s DNA profile, the ransom demand was more likely to be a hoax, weakening Howard’s case.
The Rook begins again. “Subsequently, a second package was posted to Mrs. Carlyle. What did it contain?”
“A child’s swimsuit.”
“What can you tell us about this swimsuit?”
“It was a pink-and-orange bikini, similar to the one worn by Michaela Carlyle on the day she disappeared.”
“Similar or the same one?”
“Forensic analysis couldn’t produce a definitive answer.”
The Rook is circling now. He has the face of a bird and the soul of a crocodile. “How many murders have you investigated, Detective?”
I shrug. “Upward of twenty.”
“And how many missing children cases?”
“Too many.”
“Too many to remember?”
“No, Sir.” My eyes are locked on his. “I remember every last one of them.”
The power of the statement throws him slightly. He turns back to the bar table, consulting his notepad.
“There must be a degree of pressure on the officer in charge of a high-profile investigation. A young girl is missing. Parents are scared. People want to be reassured.”
“It was a thorough investigation. We didn’t cut corners.”
“No, quite right.” He reads from a list. “Eight thousand interviews, 1,200 statements, more than a million man-hours … many of them focused on my client.”
“We followed every important lead.”
The Rook is leading me somewhere. “Were there any suspects that you didn’t pursue?”
“Not if they were important.”
“What about Gerry Brandt?”
I can feel myself hesitate. “He was a person of interest for a short time.”
“And why did you discount him?”
“We made extensive inquiries—”
“You couldn’t find him, isn’t that the case?”
“Gerry Brandt was a known drug dealer and burglar. He had contacts within the criminal underworld who I believe helped hide him.”
“This is the same man who was photographed outside Dolphin Mansions on the day Michaela disappeared?”
“That’s correct, Sir.”
He turns away from me now, addressing a wider audience. “A man with a previous conviction for sexually assaulting a minor?”
“His girlfriend.”
“A sex offender who was seen outside Dolphin Mansions but you didn’t regard him as being an important enough suspect to bother finding. Instead you focused your investigation exclusively on my client, a committed Christian, who had never been in trouble with the law. And when you obtained evidence that could suggest Michaela Carlyle might still be alive you sought to hide it.”
“I made the results available to my superiors.”
“But not to his defense.”
“With all due respect, Sir, it’s not my job to help defense lawyers.”
“You’re absolutely right, Mr. Ruiz. Your job is to establish the truth. And in this case you sought to hide the truth. You sought to ignore evidence or at worst conceal it, just as you ignored Gerry Brandt as a suspect.”
“No.”
The Rook sways back and forth on his heels. “Was the ransom demand a hoax, Detective Inspector?”
“I don’t know.”
“And are you willing to stake your career …” he corrects himself, “… your reputation and, more importantly, my client’s freedom on the absolute conviction that Michaela Carlyle was murdered three years ago?”
There’s a long pause. “No.