Piracy_ The Intellectual Property Wars from Gutenberg to Gates - Adrian Johns [132]
Beginning in September 1789, the so-called Chandos case mushroomed over four decades. The Lancashire herald, George Beltz, called it "the most extraordinary attempt ever made to attain the summit of a British patrician's ambition. "21 The dukes of Chandos had been one ofeighteenth- century England's most prominent noble families, renowned for their patronage of the arts and sciences. One of them had been responsible for the Microcosm, that device so central to arguments about creative property.22 But the last duke had just died without issue at the age of fifty-eight. It was assumed that the line had become extinct. Within a month, how ever, Brydges had persuaded his elder brother, Edward, to petition for the barony. Their claim was that they were descended from the third son of the original Baron Chandos, one John Brydges, who had been granted the rank back in 1554. (They could not claim the dukedom because that was a later creation bestowed after the family branches had diverged.) The coincidence of names aside, Brydges's conviction was at first based on sheer Romantic inspiration. He believed that the old duke had died just as he himself had been poring over old funerary inscriptions in the Chandos vault, and to his mind the coincidence could only be portentous. He also remembered hearing his mother speaking about a link, and avowed that as a child he had been surrounded by heraldry and portraits of Gibbon, Hardwicke, and Lord Chancellor Egerton (a real ancestor, on his mother's side).23 But more evidence than that would be needed to convince others of the claim. So Brydges hired the Windsor herald for what became seven longyears of researches, retained the finest London lawyers, and launched his campaign.
FIGURE 9.2. Samuel EgertonBrvdgesasavotuigman.S.E.Brvdges,The Autobiography, 2 vols. (London: Cochrane and M'Crone, 1834), vol. 1, frontispiece. Courtesy of the University of Chicago Library
FIGURE 9.3. Brydges as an old man. Brydges, Autobiography, vol. 2, frontispiece. Courtesy of the University of Chicago Library.
The resulting case became one of late Georgian England's more diverting causes celebres. It centered on questions of genealogy and documentary evidence. The opponents of Brydges's claim proposed an alternative family tree, according to which he was in fact the descendant of a quite separate fine- a humble family hailing from