Radical Judaism_ Rethinking God and Tradition - Arthur Green [38]
The metaphysical structure underlying Hasidism consists of a twofold dialectical process. Divine self-revelation is constant, uniquely present in every being and in each moment, resulting in the ever-increasing variegation of being and thus in the seeming breakup of cosmic unity into ever-smaller fragments of existence. “Seeming” is the key word here, as the deeper reality of unbroken divine oneness is the ultimate truth that is to be rediscovered and restored as a visible face of reality. Both world and Torah are products of this intentional but ultimately delusive self-fragmenting of Y-H-W-H. It is in the realms of both daily life (“serving through corporeal things”) and specific religious praxis, including prayer and study, that one is to seek out and reveal the hidden unity of Being, all roads leading back to the monistic truth. The illusion of cosmic fragmentation and distance from God is a “gift” given to the human mind in order to enable us to engage in the labors of restoration.
Philosophical sophistication or consistency was hardly the strength of these revivalist preachers, most of whose works are written in homiletical form. There are some relative exceptions to this rule, however, especially in the writings of Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, the founder of the HaBaD school, and his close disciple Rabbi Aaron of Staroselje.51 These carry the insights of the BeShT and the Maggid forward into a clearly delineated panentheistic theology of Judaism. While God as eyn sof remains utterly transcendent and mysterious, the light it gives forth shines through both in the ayin that surrounds existence and the yesh that fills it. The task of the religious mind is to understand that these make up but a single light, manifest in Torah and commandments (the self-revelation of God) as it is manifest throughout the world, since “Creation” itself is nothing but another self-manifestation of the divine glory. The pantheistic tendencies and insights found throughout the earlier mystical tradition are here presented in their most radical and systematic fashion.
With the elimination of all the intermediary sefirot, this Hasidism essentially gives up on the Kabbalistic faith in emanation. Instead it creates a theology that understands God as the eternal dialectical dance between presence and transcendence, between the revealed and the mysterious, hokhmah (sometimes parsed as KoaH MaH, a spiritualized Prime Matter) and malkhut or shekhinah, God's earthly indwelling presence. In a sense hokhmah functions here as a stand-in for eyn sof, considered too recondite even to be evoked in such a conversation. It is the deep and mysterious well out of which all existence is drawn. But the point of