Reality Matters_ 19 Writers Come Clean About the Shows We Can't Stop Watching - Anna David [59]
So how did Jersey Shore draw me in? I’d sworn off not just virtually every permutation of the classic Hanging Out with Douchebags genre of reality TV (a big, dysfunctional tent that now not only includes TRW and its imitators but also mutant strains like Keeping Up with the Kardashians and The Real Housewives franchise) in favor of much more invogue dancing/singing/cooking/sewing competition shows. Initially, I thought it might be that I was finally ready, after that long absence, to watch some more terrible people get drunk and copulate, spurred on by the belief that these would be the drunkest and copulatingest terribles MTV had produced in years. But no, that wasn’t it.
Then I realized: It’s the Guidos, stupid.
About five minutes into Jersey Shore’s (two hour!) premiere, Italian American groups began to express their displeasure about the cast’s embrace—nay exultation—of the term “Guido,” considered by many to be a slur, as well as MTV’s alleged exploitation of the group by reducing all Italians to an easily mockable Goombah stereotype. It’s a complaint Italians have heard before, most recently after some people wrongheadedly decried The Sopranos, perhaps the greatest and most nuanced television show of all time, for depicting the culture as nothing but a bunch of tracksuited, pork-store-haunting, stoolie-whacking goons. As an Italian American who grew up in a New York suburb just north of the Bronx, among friends (if not family) who were recognizable, if distant, forebears of The Shore gang (in those days, it was B.U.M. Equipment instead of Ed Hardy), Pauly D’s celebratory explanation of Guido-ness as “a lifestyle…being Italian…representing family, friends, tanning, gel, everything,” was not just the last word on a minor controversy. It was an invitation to take an inventory of my inner Guido every Thursday night. This, more than the drunken antics of some knuckleheaded kids let loose in a beach house festooned with several horrific combinations of the Italian flag and the silhouette of New Jersey, is what drew me in for the entire eight-week, nine-episode run. And when Vinny articulated the dead-simple “Gym, Tan, Laundry” formula in episode six (“That’s how they make the Guidos”), I now had a framework through which to see exactly how my own lifestyle stacked up. Let’s take each part of the New Guido Credo in turn.
GYM
The most instantly recognizable aspect of The Shore’s cast is the male roommates’ maniacal dedication to their physiques. Only Vinny, a token softy but certainly a big guy by any reasonable standard,