Starting Strength, 3rd Edition - Mark Rippetoe [25]
As we discussed earlier, the thumb should be placed on top of the bar so that the wrist can be held in a straight line with the forearm. The vast majority of people, however, will prefer to hold the bar with a thumbs-around grip. At lighter weights, this is fine because the load is easy to keep in place. But when heavier weights are being used, the grip that results from thumbs-around can create its own problems. Most people have a mental picture of the hands holding up the weight, and this usually ends up being what happens. The bar sits in the grip with the thumbs around the bar, the wrists are bent back, the elbows end up directly below the weight, and nothing really prevents the bar from sliding down the back from this position. People who do this will eventually have sore elbows, a horrible, headache-like soreness in the inside of the elbow that makes them think the injury occurred doing curls. If the elbows are underneath the weight, and the force of the weight is straight down (the nature of gravity is sometimes inconvenient), then the wrists and elbows will unavoidably intercept some of the weight (Figure 2-34). With heavy weights, the loading can be quite high, and these structures are not nearly as capable of supporting 500 pounds as the back is.
Figure 2-34. Incorrect (A) and correct (B) use of the hands and arms under the bar. Elbows should be elevated to the rear with the hands on top of the bar, not placed directly under the bar, where they intercept part of the weight.
If the thumbs are on top of the bar, the hands can assume a position that is straight in line with the forearms when the elbows are raised. If you are accustomed to letting your wrists relax into extension and letting your elbows drop, your grip might be too narrow for your shoulder flexibility, and a slightly wider grip would make straight wrists easier to maintain. You might also need to actively “curl” the wrist into what will feel like flexion if you have been passively allowing it to extend. In the correct position, the wrist is straight, neither flexed nor extended; none of the weight is over any part of the arm, wrist, or hand; and all of the weight is on the back (Figure 2-34). Learn to carry all of the weight of the bar safely on your back before your strength improves to the point where this same weight carried in your hands – and thus on your wrists and elbows – can become a problem.
Occasionally a person gets misled into thinking that it is okay to put the hands out so wide on the bar that the fingers or even the palms of the hands are in contact with the plates. Bizarre as this sounds, you will eventually see this in the gym. As grip width increases, upper-back muscle tightness decreases and muscular support for the bar is diminished, as previously discussed. If the posterior deltoids, rotator cuff muscles, traps, and rhomboids relax due to a widened grip, the skeleton becomes the default support structure. This is less than desirable. To add to the problem by placing the hands on the plates – a ROTATING pair of objects at the far end of the bar – is just silly. You must be in control of the bar, and this means that it must be secure on your back and therefore in your grip.
As is often the case in athletics, one problem is intimately associated with another, and the solving of one fixes the other. A lack of shoulder tightness and failure to keep the chest up are related problems and must be corrected together. If your elbows drop, your shoulders relax; if you lift your elbows, your shoulders