The Fifth Witness - Michael Connelly [82]
“All I know is that I saw her. She was there.”
“And she was even carrying a big shopping bag, you say, correct?”
“That’s right.”
“What kind of shopping bag?”
“The kind with handles, the kind you get in a department store.”
“What color was it?”
“It was red.”
“And could you tell if it was full or empty?”
“I couldn’t tell.”
“And she carried this down at her side or in front of her?”
“Down at her side. With one hand.”
“You seem to have a good sense of this bag. Were you looking at the bag or the face of the woman who was carrying it?”
“I had time to look at both.”
I shook my head as I looked at my notes.
“Ms. Schafer, do you know how tall Ms. Trammel is?”
I turned to my client and signaled her to stand up. I probably should have asked the judge’s permission first but I was on a roll and didn’t want to hit any speed bumps. Perry said nothing.
“I have no idea,” Schafer said.
“Would it surprise you to know she is only five foot three?”
I nodded to Lisa and she sat back down.
“No, I don’t think that would surprise me.”
“Five foot three and you still picked her out across four lanes packed with cars.”
Freeman objected as I knew she would. Perry sustained the objection but I didn’t need an answer for the point to be made. I checked my watch and saw it was two minutes before noon. I fired my final torpedo.
“Ms. Schafer, can you look at the photograph and point to where you see the defendant on the sidewalk?”
All eyes moved to the photo blowup. Because of the line of cars in the parking lane, the pedestrians on the sidewalk were unidentifiable in the image. Freeman leapt to her feet and objected, claiming the defense was trying to sandbag the witness and the court. Perry called us to a sidebar. When we got there, he had stern words for me.
“Mr. Haller, yes or no, is the defendant in the photo?”
“No, Your Honor.”
“Then you’re engaged in attempting to trick the witness. That will not happen in my courtroom. Take your photo down.”
“Judge, I’m not trying to trick anyone. She could simply say that the defendant is not in the photo. But she clearly can’t see the pedestrians on the other side of the traffic and I am trying to make that clear to—”
“I don’t care what you’re trying to do. Take your photo down and if you try another move like that you’re going to find yourself in a contempt hearing at the close of business. Understood?”
“Yes, sir.”
“Your Honor,” Freeman said. “The jury should be told that the defendant is not in the photo.”
“I agree. Go back.”
On my way back to the lectern I took the display boards off the easel.
“Ladies and gentlemen,” the judge said. “Let it be noted that the defendant was not in the photo that defense counsel put on display.”
The jury instruction was fine with me. I still made my point. The fact that the jurors had to be told that Lisa was not in the photo underlined how hard it would have been to see and identify someone on the sidewalk.
The judge told me to continue my cross-examination and I leaned to the microphone.
“No further questions.”
I sat down and put the photo boards on the floor under the table. They had served me well. I took the hit from the judge but it was worth it. It’s always worth it if you make your point.
Twenty-three
Lisa Trammel was ecstatic about my cross-examination of Margo Schafer. Even Herb Dahl couldn’t hold back from congratulating me as the trial was recessed for lunch. I counseled them not to get overly excited. It was early in the trial and eyewitnesses like Schafer were usually the easiest to handle and damage on the stand. There were still tough witnesses and tougher days ahead. They could count on that.
“I don’t care,” Lisa said. “You were marvelous and that lying bitch got just what she deserved.”
The invective was dripping with hate and it made me pause for a moment before responding.
“The prosecutor is still going to have a chance to rehabilitate her on redirect after lunch.”
“And then you can destroy her again on re-cross.”
“Well… I don’t know about destroying anybody. That’s not what—”
“Can you join