The Portable Edgar Allan Poe - Edgar Allan Poe [97]
Antagonisms
During his turbulent professional career, Poe counted among his enemies shameless editors, exploitative publishers, hostile reviewers, hated coteries, and acquaintances who had (in his view) insulted or betrayed him in private life. His indignation at perceived injustices sprang in part from clashes with his foster father that culminated in Poe’s abandonment and disinheritance.
Adopting the motto of John Allan’s native Scotland, “Nemo me impune lacessit” (no one wounds me with impunity), Poe turned instinctively as a writer to themes of hostility, rivalry, and revenge. His first published story, “Metzengerstein,” savors of German romanticism in evoking “metempsychosis”—the soul’s transmigration at death to a human or animal form. An “ancient prophecy” portends the outcome of a feud between warring families, and Poe hints that after Count Berlifitzing dies in a fire, trying to rescue his prized horses, he avenges himself against Baron Metzengerstein (the presumed arsonist) by taking the form of a gigantic “fiery-colored horse.”
A more intimate struggle informs “William Wilson,” a tale based in part on Poe’s memories of an English boarding school. The narrator’s antipathy for his nemesis, a youth whose name is identical to his own, ends in pathological derangement as Poe finally puts in question the existence of the hated rival. Doubling abounds in Poe, but here the doppelgänger motif elaborates the conflict of a self torn between impulsive depravity and ineluctable conscience.
The intensity of “The Tell-Tale Heart” develops as much from the narrator’s mad need to contradict an assumed imputation of madness as from his account of murdering and dismembering an old man. When he succumbs, under police questioning, to the delusion that he hears the dead man’s beating heart, his confession discloses more derangement than remorse. His admitted need to rid himself of the old man’s “vulture eye” hints that he shares his victim’s dread of death.
In “The Black Cat,” Poe calls the irrational urge to commit gratuitous atrocities “the spirit of PERVERSENESS.”